Tuesday, July 24, 2012

Dilemma of an Indian Expat in the Middle East


I often try and pull myself away from the minutiae of my daily life to look at the bigger picture. However, being a creature of habit and routine and with my days filled with quotidian rhythms this does not happen too often.

 
But when it does, I try and figure out what and where I want my life to be a few years down the road. It goes without saying that the view is murky in the extreme, but what is more frightening is the fact that caught where I am on the crossroads of two worlds, it is extremely difficult to even know what "to" want. Let me re-emphasize the word "to". I deliberately did not say what "I" want! The winds of change are blowing hard across the Globe, and I think that they will be reaching gale force soon. We are like flotsam caught in the inexorable push and pull of huge tidal forces.

 
Based here in the Middle East, it feels (to me) like the center of the world - not in the sense of any pre-eminence, just that it is perfectly situated between the West and the East. I delude myself into thinking that it provides me with a unique perspective. Positioned between the Developed and the Under-Developed Geographies, between the Ageing and the Younger Populations, between the Mature and the Frontier Economies. But also on the fault line between the Clean and the Polluted, between the Sparsely-populated and the Over-populated, between the Sophisticated and the Rough, and between the First World Welfare States and the Third World Developing Countries.

 
My head starts to swim with questions that seem to pop up out of nowhere and everywhere.
So where should we go from here? I feel like we are caught between a rock and a hard place or more pertinently (like) people scared of heights stuck midway up a steep slope, wherein one can neither go ahead nor climb down.
Should I encourage my children to look West, and forever sever any ties they have to their identities and their homeland?
Or would it be better to mentally prepare them to look only East, knowing in my heart that a growing economy is no guarantee of a better quality and standard of living?

 
On the one hand
As the world's economic might shifts to the Third World, a lot of the Immigrants to the West, will start facing the heat, as jobs and money gets tighter. Those Governments will have no choice but to protect the rights and the jobs of the "native" populations. Even if not overtly stated, the undercurrents of racism and discrimination will make life a bit less idyllic, as the economic climate cools.
Will countries like Canada and Australia which today seem welcoming, feel the same to an immigrant a few years hence?
Will the specter of racism ever diminish, or will it only be exacerbated by the collapsing paradigm of Western Economic might and infinite growth?
How long can and will the West keep printing money to keep their people happy, before their economies implode, with all the consequences that follow?
Even if their wealth is welcomed, will the people themselves from China and the Sub-continent, who might act and look boorish and unrefined, be welcome?
And will it not be worse for their children, who get assimilated into their borrowed homeland and lose their native identity, when they come face to face with the consequences of deep rooted prejudices?
For how long will the ingrained disdain of the East be masked by the West's desperation to survive?

 
On the other hand
Can we go back to the conditions that we came from and our children have never seen?
Will we be able to adapt to a culture and philosophy that is circular rather than linear?
How can one adapt to a place where nothing works as it should, and even if we can adapt, will we be happy?
Are we looking back to our homeland because we do not want to get out of our comfort zone, or will the reality of the familiar actually embrace and shelter us?
Can we be content in a place that cannot provide its people basic amenities, and every day is a battle for survival?

 
Positioned here on the Lagrange point of two opposing civilizations and cultures, one looks both ways to find answers. In this place which professes to be the melting pot of more than a hundred and fifty Nationalities and many diverse cultures, it becomes evident that if one strips away the superficiality of forced inclusiveness, the words West is West and East is East, and never the Twain shall meet, rings quite true.


 
So many questions and I have not thought the half of them. And an infinite range of answers to each! It makes my head swim! But the incessant drumbeat of Time is only accelerating, as my son now stands positioned to leave the roost. As he strains on the leash to be let go, the urgency of seeking answers gets strident.

 
Then I hear, in my mind, my In-Laws oft repeated refrain, that I think too much. I try and control too much of what cannot be controlled. Life will take care of itself, and in the process answer most of these questions.

 
The question 'then' is - will the answers be palatable?

5 comments:

Rustom said...

Agree with your in-laws :)

Young adults with the right value system ingrained will do OK on either side of the world ... as the last time I checked the sun still rises on both sides, albeit at different times.

What a joyous existence we resident Indians have .... with no such dilemma to burden our shoulders .... no choice but to get ourselves dirty in the mother of all rat races with the sole objective of just SURVIVING in the hope that one day India will truly shine ...... and maybe even dying in despair ...... but yet it will be a life well spent .... thanks to friendships like ours!!!

I see you have already made the move of letting your son get a whiff of the intoxication of working life in India!!!
Rustom

Anonymous said...

The dilema is only within your head, and it is you who looks at it negatively. Being in between the two Civilisations means that you have a good understanding of both and therefore have the ability to go wherever you want whenever you wish. This is a competitve advantage versus most in either civilisation. Prepare them to take advantage of both civilisations
RM

Anonymous said...

Hi Zubs,

Just want to add that what you refer to as the other side, ( Dirty, struggle,etc) is more than what you have seen. we have been fortunate to live & grow in a city like mumbai , which is no doubt in a mess. However, unlike most of the gang I have seen the other side of India. If you feel that Mumbai does not work then you have not seen anything. Go to the rural areas & the poverty will sting you.
law & Order are just words there.I always thank God for giving me a life in Mumbai & that too South mumbai. While your blog can ensure a great debate over a cup of coffee or Single malt, in reality just let the kids look west for their future. it would be unfair on them to go backwards.
kerman

Anonymous said...

Nice read. All I can say here is that do not over analyse. We left the shores of India to make a better life. Of course what India offers today in terms of money we did not get but does more money equate to a better standard of living? The standard of living has actually deteriorated from the time we have left.



Further, a 1st world country passport does indeed open all doors…. literally. You are an equal citizen with equal recourse to the justice system. In the Middle East one could never hope to be, and in India, our own country, we would lose out to the corruption & underworld.



Prejudices are prevalent everywhere. Even in B’bay we have the bhaiyas, ghatis and the gangas. Would our friends appreciate that their children play football with the ramas! Here the Surgeon’s son or the CEO’s son could be playing shoulder to shoulder with a plumber’s son or a brick layer.

There will always be a few bogans who will beat up and cuss at a ‘foreigner’ under the cloak of patriotism not realizing that the ‘foreigner’ is paying the taxes that is supporting his family and him. These bogans work to the detriment of the country. Personally, I have yet to come across any individual or family who has suffered under prejudice. We always hear about it but have never really seen it close up.



For the first time in my life I do not have to scramble for a visa to get into a country. It is a feeling I cannot put into words. Imagine a scenario where we have the money to afford a top Ivy league Uni but could not get a visa to that country. This happens and we know it 1st hand.



Most importantly, our children and us need to have an option. There is nothing stopping us from getting back home (India) once the children have settled down. This is not to say we are doing it for them…..it is as much for us as for them.

The facilities, ease of life, work life balance, makes one feel healthy (in body & mind) and it shows. I also understand that a steady job is the basic foundation but that can shake anywhere in the world.



All the ho ha about doing house work yourself is hardly true. People make it out to be far more than it is. The services of a maid would go a long way, h’ever it is not insurmountable and loading a dish washer and putting clothes out to dry really does not cramp your life style. We keep our house clean & tidy, cook our meals, entertain & be entertained, go to work and yet have time to read a book or a magazine.



In the end it is the mind set and the comfort zone that one has to overcome.



Regards……….Aspi.

Zarir said...


Very well written Aspi.